The Wound healing, anti inflammatory and haemostatic
effect of Eupatorium odoratum
R. Suresh*, D. Benito Johnson, Appalaraju Gorle, Ashok Kumar Javvadi, Tamil Selvan A.
Department of Pharmacology, R.V.S. College Pharmaceutical Science,
Sulur, Coimbatore-640 402
ABSTRACT:
Wound is perhaps an inescapable event in the life of an
organism. Healing process begins during the early
phase of inflammation, but reaches completion usually after the injurious
influence has been neutralized. It should be emphasized that without
inflammation wounds would never heal. Eupatorium odoratum Linn. (Family: Compositae) is a perennial herb growing widely in the south
of the country. The wound healing effect of ethanol extract of E. odoratum was studied using, re sutured incision wound,
excision wound model, dead space wound model and the results obtained by the
three models were compared and found that excision wound model is statistically
significant (p<0.01). The anti inflammatory activity of ethanol- leaf
extract of E. odoratum was evaluated using carregeenan induced paw edema in rats, there was no
statistically significant change in the drug treated compared to the control
and the haemostatic activity assessed by capillary tube method, there was a
statically significant reduction in the blood coagulation time
KEY WORDS: wound
healing, anti inflammatory, haemostatic, Eupatorium odoratum
INTRODUCTION:
One of the important attributes of
life is its capacity for self repair. Wound healing represents a restoration of
continuity of living cells and overlaps the inflammatory process1-2.
The process of wound healing has been one of the earliest medical problems.
Healing is essential for survival mechanisms and represents an attempt to
maintain normal anatomical structure and function3. Healing of a
wound is an important biological process involving tissue repairs and
regeneration. It involves the activity of an intricate network of blood cells,
cytokines and growth factors which ultimately leads to the restoration to the
normal condition of the injured skin or tissue4. The aim of wound care is to
promote wound healing in the shortest time possible, with minimal pain,
discomfort and scarring to the patient and must occur in a physiologic
environment conducive to tissue repair and regeneration5. Wound
healing processes are known to be influenced by among other factors by
infections, nutritional status, drugs and hormones, types and sites of wound
and wasting diseases like diabetes6. Eupatorium odoratum, belonging to the compositae
family, is a perennial herb growing widely in various parts of South America
and tropical countries. The leaf juice of this plant has been used to apply on
wounds by village people. It has been reported that leaf juice of this plant
has been used to stop bleeding and has also anti microbial activity. The
present study is undertaken mainly to evaluate the effect of the ethanol
extract of E.odoratum like wound
healing on various types of wounds, anti inflammatory action, blood coagulation7.
The greatest contribution of plant kingdom to mankind is that it has provided a
large variety of potent drugs to alleviate suffering from diseases.
In spite of spectacular advances
in the synthetic drugs in recent years some of the drugs of plant origin have
still retain their importance. In recent years there is a great deal of use of
plant based drugs in the western countries.
MATERIALS AND METHODS:
Animals
Healthy male albino rats weighing
between 150-250g were used. They were individually housed and maintained on
animal chow and water ad libitum. The protocol of the experiments was approved
by the Institutional Animal Ethical Committee (IAEC) of R.V.S. College of
Pharmaceutical Sciences, Coimbatore, Tamilnadu, and
according with the guidelines of the Committee for Purpose of Control and
Supervision of Experiments on Animals (CPCSEA), Ethical guidelines were
strictly followed during all the experiments. The rats were starved for 36
hours with free access to water, before infliction of wounds. The anesthetic administered was Phenobarbitone
(dose-20mg/kg weight of rat), supplemented with ether whenever necessary. No
local or systemic chemotherapeutic agents were used. The surgical materials
were stabilized and skin was prepared by clipping the fur and cleaning with 70%
alcohol before wounding.
MATERIALS
The general surgical materials including anaesthetics were obtained from R.V.S. Hospital Pharmacy.
Drugs Control
Animals were given only 2% Tween
80 orally, since the E.odoratum ethanol
extract suspension was made with the help of Tween 80
Plant material and extraction
The E. odoratum Linn was
collected from south Coimbatore in the month of April and was authenticated by
Professor Dr. R. Venkatanarayan, Department of
Pharmacognosy, R.V.S College of pharmaceutical
sciences. The air dried leaves of E.odoratum was used
for the study. The coarse powder of the leaves (2kg) was extracted with 95%
ethanol under reflux in a round bottom flask in batches of 500g each. Each
batch was extracted for two hours. The extracts were then concentrated under
reduced pressure till it acquires semisolid consistency. This was then allowed
to evaporate to dryness.
Preliminary phytochemical analysis
The ethanol extract of Eupatorium odoratum
was subjected to preliminary phytochemical Screening for detection of major
chemical groups. In each case test 10% w/v solution of the extract in ethanol
was used and unless otherwise mentioned in individual test. Results of
different chemical tests on the ethanol extract of Eupatorium odoratum showed the presence of Phytoconstituents
viz., steroids, triterpene, alkaloids and flavonoids
Acute toxicity studies
Healthy adult albino rats starved overnight were divided
into four groups (n=5) and were given different doses of the extract. Group I
0.25g/kg orally, Group II 0.50g/kg orally, Group III 1g/kg orally, Group IV
2g/kg orally. The animals were observed continuously every five minute, every
ten minutes for one hour and at the end of twenty four hours. Since no animal
died even in the maximum dose of 2g/kg of body weight, 1/10th of it
i.e. 200mg/kg of body weight was selected for the study.
WOUND HEALING MODELS
a) Resuture dincision
wound:
This wound model was utilized
to study the breaking strength of the incision wound in rats. Duration of study
and treatment is 10 days8. The animals divided into two groups each
group containing five animals. Group-I: control 2% Tween
80, dose-2ml/kg orally. Group-II: Ethanol extract of E. odoratum,
dose-200mg/kg orally. Six centimeters long paravertiberal
straight incisions were made, one centimeter lateral to the vertebral column on
either side through the entire thickness of skin9. Intermittent
sutures were placed one centimeter apart with the help of black silk thread.
The wounds were then mopped with cotton swab soaked in the 70% alcohol. The
animals received the drugs once every day throughout the period of study
sutures were removed on the 7th post operative day. Wound breaking
strength was measured on the 10th day by continuous constant water
flow technique as described by Lee. The anaesthetized animals were placed on
the operation table, to allis forceps were firmly
applied on either side of the wound at a distance of 5mm from the wound margin.
One forceps was hooked to the fixed metal rod and the other forceps was
connected to a light plastic gratitude bottle, through a string run over a
pulley. The bottle was connected to a constant running water stream which had
stop cock to arrest the flow.
Table-1 Showed resuture incision
wound model
|
No of Animal |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
5 |
Mean± S.E |
|
Control |
503.3 |
531.6 |
470.0 |
510.0 |
492.0 |
501.38±10.15 |
|
Drug treated |
548.3 |
436.7 |
421.6 |
460.0 |
511.6 |
475.64±23.72 |
Table-2 showed excision wound model
|
Day |
2 |
4 |
6 |
8 |
10 |
12 |
14 |
16 |
18 |
20 |
22 |
|
Control |
1.18± 0.747 |
3.1± 1.16 |
18.8± 7.05 |
26.3± 8.40 |
55.8± 6.60 |
67.8± 6.60 |
74.4± 1.15 |
74.4± 1.15 |
78.8± 3.40 |
86.9± 1.6 |
90.9± 1.78 |
|
Drug treated |
10.9± 5.58 |
26.7**± 6.86 |
36.0± 7.38 |
38.2± 7.13 |
68.7± 4.25 |
76.9*± 3.40 |
80.1± 2.93 |
83.7± 3.01 |
87.8± 2.52 |
90.5± 2.47 |
96.8± 2.66 |
*p < 0.02
**p < 0.01
Tensile strength was measured by allowing the water into
the bottle and thus gradually increasing its weight which causes disruption of
the wound. As soon as gapping of wound was observed, the flow was stopped and
the volume of water in the bottle was noted. For such readings were taken on
either side of the wound to give eight readings. The average of such 8 readings in each animal
of any group was taken to calculate the average tensile strength of each animal
averages, mean value for group was calculated and showed in table-1
b) Excision wound model:
This model was employed to study the rate of wound
contraction and epithelization. The parameter
monitored was median wound contraction time and epithelization
period10. Duration of treatment and study is twenty two days. The
animals divided into two groups, each group containing six animals. Group-I:
Control-2% Tween 80, dose-2ml/kg orally. Group-II:
Ethanol extract of E. odoratum,
dose-200mg/kg orally. Round seal of 2.5cm in diameter (500mm) was impressed on
the dorsal thoracic region 5 cm away from the ears, as described by Morton and
molone54 under light anesthesia. The entire full thickness of skin
from the marked area was excised Wound were cleaned with cotton swab soaked in
70% alcohol. Animals received drugs daily from “0” day till wounds completely
healed or up to 21st post operative day, which ever was earlier.
Contraction which mainly contributes for wound closure, was studied by tracing
the raw wound area on polythene paper every alternate day till wounds were
completely covered with epithelium. These wound tracings were retraced on a
millimeter scale graph paper, to determine the wound area. Then wound closure
was expressed as a percent of original wound size (500 mm2) for a
group and group mean on particular day was taken for final analysis of the
results. Employing Litchfield and Wilcoxon analytical
method11, the W.C-50 in days was estimated and its S.E calculated by
the method described by Ghosh12. Epithelization
period was monitored by noting the number of days required for eschar to fall away leaving no raw wound behind and
calculations showed in table-2.
c) Dead space wound:
This method is usually employed for assessing the extent
of collagenation13. The dead space wounds were created to harvest
granulation by implanting the subcutaneously, 2.5×0.5cm polypropylene tubes14
in the dorsal region, through a small (0.5cm) transverse incision about four to
five centimeters cephaloid to the site of
implantation. Drugs were administered once daily from day’0’ to day’9’. On day
‘10’, the granulation tissue harvested on the implanted tube was carefully
dissected out along with the tube after anaesthetizing the rat.
This is used to monitor breaking strength and dry weight
of granuloma. Duration oftreatment
and study is 10 days. The animals were divided into two groups, each group
containing eight animals. Group-I: control 2% Tween
80, dose-2ml/kg orally. Group-II: ethanol extract of E. odoratum, dose-200mg/kg orally. The
tubular granulation was cut along its length, to obtain a sheet of granulation
tissue, which was further cut into two approximately equal pieces. The
breaking/tensile strength of each piece was measured as by the method of Lee15,
and the mean was calculated. After measuring the breaking strength, the pieces
of the granulation tissues were collected, dried at 60oc for 24
hours and weighed. The dried granuloma weight was
taken expressed as a mg/100g of rat and calculations
showed in table-3.
ANTI INFLAMMATORY STUDY
There are various models acute and chronic for screening
of anti inflammatory agents.
Carrageenan induced
paw edema in rats:
The procedure adopted is that of winter et al16
.one hour after drug administration, a sub plantar injection of 0.05 ml of
1%solution of carrageenan was injected into the left
hind paw. The paw volume was determined immediately according to the method of
Bhatt et al17 .This volume was designated
as ‘0’ hours volume. The volume of injected paw was again measured affter three hours and designated as ‘3’ hours volume;
difference between these two was taken as actual increase in the paw volume was
showed in table no 4, 5. Mean increase in paw volume was calculated, and then
the percent inhibition of edema was calculated by using the formula.
Percentage of inhibition=100(1-Vt/Vc)
Where Vt
= Increase in paw volume of treated group.
Vc =Increase in paw volume of
control group.
Table-3 showed dead space wound model
|
No. of animals |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
5 |
6 |
7 |
8 |
Mean± S.E |
|
Control |
525 |
485 |
535 |
490 |
545 |
495 |
575 |
520 |
521.25± 10.89 |
|
Drug treated |
565 |
485 |
265 |
395 |
365 |
433 |
550 |
600 |
457.10± 40.38 |
Table-4 showed acute inflammation (paw volume at third
hour)
|
No of animals |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
5 |
6 |
7 |
Mean± S.E. ml |
|
Control |
0.8 |
0.4 |
0.4 |
0.2 |
0.26 |
0.52 |
0.38 |
0.42± 0.074 |
|
Drug treated |
0.64 |
0.72 |
0.12 |
0.68 |
0.00 |
0.58 |
0.28 |
0.43± 0.11 |
Table-5 showed chronic inflammation(weight
of granulation tissue in mg/100g of body weight)
|
No of animals |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
5 |
6 |
7 |
8 |
Mean± S.E |
|
Control |
0.03 |
0.04 |
0.04 |
0.04 |
0.04 |
0.042 |
0.031 |
0.049 |
0.039± 0.002 |
|
Drug treated |
0.036 |
0.031 |
0.035 |
0.046 |
0.023 |
0.031 |
0.067 |
0.076 |
0.043± 0.006 |
Table-6 blood coagulation (in minute/sec):
|
No of animals |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
5 |
6 |
mean± S.E |
|
Control |
13 |
13 |
8.5 |
9.5 |
10 |
11 |
10.8± 0.76 |
|
Drug treated |
4.5 |
2 |
2.5 |
3.0 |
2 |
2 |
2.66± 0.40 |
P < 0.001
HAEMOSTATIC EFFECT
Effect of blood coagulation was determined by capillary
tube method. Twelve albino male rats were selected; six rats were treated with
ethanol extract 200mg/kg orally once daily for 10 days. The six rats were for
control, i.e. 1ml of 2%Tween 80 per kg of rat for 10 days. The initial blood
clotting time was noted by the capillary tube of about 10-15 cm length. A part
of the capillary tube was broken each minute. The elapsing from the moment the
wound was made to that when fine thread of fibrin appeared between the ends of
the broken sections of the tube was taken as the clotting time. The results
were showed in table-6.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION:
Wounds are the physical injuries
that results in an opening or break of the skin. Proper healing of wounds is
essential for the restoration of disrupted anatomical continuity and disrupted
functional response of the several cell types to injury. Cutaneous
wound repair is accompanied by an ordered and definable sequence of biological
events starting with wound closure and progressing to the repair and remodeling of damaged tissue18. In spite of
tremendous advances in the chemical drug industry, the availability of
substances capable of stimulating the process of wound repair is still limited19.
Moreover the management of chronic wounds is another major problem due to high
cost therapy and presence of side effects20. Wound healing is a natural process of
regenerating dermal and epidermal tissues. Whenever there is wound, a set of
overlapping events takes place to repair the damage. These processes have been
categorized into phases which include the inflammatory, proliferative and
remodelling phases21. In the inflammatory phase, bacteria and debris are phagocytosed and removed and cytokines and mediator are
released that cause the migration and division of cells involved in the proliferative
phase. Angiogenesis, collagen deposition, granulation tissue formation, epithelization and wound contraction occur in the
proliferative phase23. During epithelization, the
epithelial cells crawl across the wound bed to cover it23. The
wound is eventually closed by a combination of all these and by the process of
wound contracture. During wound contraction, the wound is made smaller by the
action of myofibroblasts, which establish a grip on
the wound edges and contract themselves using a mechanism similar to that in
smooth muscle cells. In the maturation and remodeling
phase, Collagen is remolded and realigned along
tension lines and cells that are no longer needed are removed by apoptosis24
In the present study, all three wound models were employed
to evaluate the action of the indigenous drug E.odoratum,
since no single model can monitor all the phases of healing. From the study, it
was observed that the drug had no significant effect on any phase of healing,
as evidenced by tensile strength, wound contraction rate and epithelization period. Epithelization
time was prolonged (control: 21 days, drug treated: 22 days). Wound contraction
rate on the fourth post wounding day was 26.7±6.8% as compared to the
controls(3.1±1.2,p≤0.01)
where as by the 12th day the rates were comparable(control:67.8±6.6;
drug treated:76.94±3.0, p≤0.02). Hence the drug seems to be effective in
space dening contraction only in the early stage of
healing. The tensile strength of skin (incision wound) and granuloma
tissue (dead space wound) of drug treated animals were also comparable to
controls. Skin tissue: control 501±10.59; dug treated: 475±23.7; granuloma tissue: control 521±10.9; drug treated: 457±40.4.
In Incision wound model and Dead space wound model are there is no
statistically significant change in the tensile strength of the given drug as
compared to the control. In Excision wound model there is a statistically
significant increase in the rate of wound contraction in drug treated animals
on 4th and 12th
day as compared to the normal control. Inflammation there is no statistically
significant change in the drug treated group as compared with control. However E.odoratum showed significant haemostatic effect evidenced
by reduction in clotting time in the capillary tube method.
CONCLUSION:
In conclusion, it can be reported that the indigenous drug
E. odoratum was found to be ineffective as prohealer. However, since it has antimicrobial action
associated with haemostatic effect, it has potential to be used locally to
arrest bleeding or hemorrhages of this drug. Earlier reports of this drug being
useful in the process of wound healing these may be due to its antiseptic
action in keeping the wound germ free rather than enhancing the healing
process.
REFERENCES:
1.
Nalwaya N, Pokharna G, Dob L, Jain N. Wound
healing activity of Calotropis gigantea. International Journal of Pharmacy and
Pharmaceutical Sciences 2009; 1(1): 176-80.
2.
Jain S, Jain N, Tiwari A, Balekar N, Jain DK.
Simple evaluation of wound healing activity of polyherbal
formulation of roots of Ageratum conyzoides L.
Asian J Research Chem 2009; 2 (2):135-8.
3.
Bhat S, Shankrappa J, Shivkumar
HG. Formulation and evaluation of polyherbal wound
treatments. Asian Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences 2007; 2 (1): 11-7.
4.
Clark RAF Cutaneous wound repairs. In: Goldsmith LA editors.
Physiology: Biochemistry and Molecular Biology of skin. New York: Oxford
University Press; 1991. 576.
5.
Bowler PG, Duerden BI, Armstrong DG. Wound microbiology and associated
approaches to wound management. Clin. Microbial Rev
2001; 14: 244-69.
6.
Karl M, Lacrix
PV, Peterson HH, editors. Canine Surgery. 4th ed. American Veterinary
Publication., California; 42-5.
7.
Indian Journal of Crude drug
Research. 28(4) :
253-256.
8.
Mallikarjun R.C., Ashok Kumar, Kulkarni D.R. Ind J Physiol Pharmacol
1988a; 32; 61-66.
9.
Ehrlich H.P., Hunt T.K. Ann Surg 1969: 170:203-06
10.
Morton JJ, Malone MH.
Evaluation of vulnerary activity by an open wound procedure in rats. Arch Int Pharmacodyn Ther. 1972; 196: 117-26.
11.
Litchfield J.T., Wilcoxon F.A. J Pharmacol Exp
Therapy.1949; 95; 99-100.
12.
Ghosh M.N. Fundaments of experimental pharmacology. Toxicities studies
2nd edn .Ghosh
M.N. ed, Scientific Book
Agency Calcutta. 1984a; pp 153-158.
13.
Lee KH. Studies on mechanism
of action of salicylates II, Retardation of wound
healing by asprin. J. Pharm. Sci. 1968; 57: 1042-43.
14.
Arthur K.C., Ehrlich H.P., Trelstad R.L., Koraly M.J. Ann
Surg. 1980; 191; 244-48.
15.
Lee K.H. J Pharm sci.1968a; 57;1042-43;
16.
Winter C.A., Risly E.A., Nusa G, W. Proc Soc Exp Biol
Med 1962; 11; 544-47.
17.
Bhatt K. R., R.K., Shrivastava P. N. Ind J Physiol Pharmacology.1977; 21; 399-400.
18.
Odimegwu DC, Ibezim EC, Esimone
CO, Nworu CS, Okoye F B.
Wound healing and antibacterial activities of the extract Dissotis
theifolia (Melastomataceae)
stem formulated in a simple ointment base. J. Medicinal Plant Res. 2003; 2(1):
011-16.
19.
Rathi B, Pathi PA, Baheti
AM. Evaluation of aqueous extract of pulp and seeds of Moringo
oliefera for wound healing in albino rats. J
Natural Remedies. 4: 145-49.
20.
Bele A, Jadhav V, Kadum
VJ. Wound healing activity of herbal formulation. Journal of Pharmacy Research
2009; 2(2) : 344-48.
21.
Stadelmann VK, Digenis AG, Tohin
GR. Impediments to wound healing. Am J Surg. 1998; 176:39S-47S.
22.
Midwood KS, Williams LV, Schwarzbaur JE, Tissue
repair and the dynamics of the extracellular matrix. Int
J Boichem Cell Biol. 2004; 36(6): 1031-37.
23.
Garg HG, Scarless wound healing. New York:
Marcel Dekkar Inc. Electronic book. 2000.
24.
Esimone CO, Nworu CS, Jackson CL. Cutaneous wound healing activity of a
herbal ointment containing the leaf extract of Jatropha
curcas L. (Euphorbiaceae).
International Journal of Applied Research in Natural Products 2009; 1(4):1-4.
Received on 29.10.2011
Modified on 27.11.2011
Accepted on 29.11.2011
© A&V Publication all right reserved
Research Journal of Pharmacognosy and Phytochemistry.
4(2): March-April 2012,
75-79